Protect your people,
property, and reputation

Learn More Get A Quote

Have a Representative Contact You Directly

Leadership Lessons

Learn why Dr. Todd Marrah, superintendent of Tree of Life Christian Schools, envisions education transforming over the next decade, how he empowers his school’s leaders, and why there’s sound reasoning for the head of school to spend time off campus to network and build donor relations.

Listen Now

Property & Liability

Brotherhood Mutual’s property insurance offers protection for physical items—from songbooks to steeples.

Discover Your Options

Commercial Auto Insurance

For your ministry vehicles.

Learn More

Workers’ Compensation Insurance

Protect your employees and your ministry.

Cover Your Staff

Safety Library

Browse hundreds of articles, checklists, and sample forms.

Visit the Library

Now's The Best Time To Evaluate Your Church Payroll Process

Learn How Call 866.215.5540

What Our Customers Say

“Other carriers might offer coverage for less money, but it’s not the same service as we get from Brotherhood Mutual. Quality and price are both important. We get a good value for our needs.”

Jon Bisset, Executive Director
River Valley Ranch

Read More