100 Years

Advancing the Kingdom by Serving the Church®

A Century of Service

Insuring America's Churches and Related Ministries®

Our company was founded by a community of believers united in Christian brotherhood. We believed then as we believe now that the Church is more than a building and that every insurance payment is a hard-earned tithe or offering.

Even though we’ve grown over the past 100 years, one thing has remained the same – our unwavering commitment to faithfully and joyfully serving America’s churches, schools, and camps.

Thank you for letting us be a part of your ministry.

About Us

Have an Agent Contact You Directly

Property & Liability Coverage

Discover Your Options

Commercial Auto Insurance

For your ministry vehicles

Learn More

Workers’ Compensation Insurance

Protect your employees and your ministry

Cover Your Staff

MinistryWorks® Payroll Services

Payroll services to ease your administrative burdens

Learn More

Mission Travel Insurance

For your mission travel and medical emergencies

Insure Your Mission

What Our Customers Say

“Other carriers might offer coverage for less money, but it’s not the same service as we get from Brotherhood Mutual. Quality and price are both important. We get a good value for our needs.”

Jon Bisset, Executive Director
River Valley Ranch

Read More