Steve Case

Steve Case
JD, CPCU

Vice President
General Counsel Affiliates

Steve Case has been in his current role since 2024, which is responsible for providing strategic leadership, oversight, and management of the legal and compliance functions of Brotherhood Mutual’s affiliate and subsidiary entities.
 
He joined the company in 2014 and has previously held the roles of associate corporate counsel, assistant vice president/senior corporate counsel, and assistant vice president, general counsel – affiliates. Prior to joining Brotherhood Mutual, he worked in insurance defense litigation.

"My church has a motto: To grow larger, we have to become smaller. That is, we have to focus on building relationships and remaining relevant with every individual who attends. Brotherhood Mutual embodies this same vision by remaining focused on building meaningful relationships with the ministries we serve, even as we experience tremendous growth. I thoroughly enjoy meeting with and speaking to ministry leaders about the issues that matter to them."

After receiving his bachelor's degree from Manchester University, Steve received his Juris Doctor degree from the University of Toledo College of Law. He received his CPCU designation in 2017.

Steve is a member of the Christian Legal Society, Defense Research Institute, Association of Corporate Counsel, and Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel. He attends The Pointe Church in Fort Wayne, where he previously served as the Grow Group director and now serves on the ministry advisory board.