Annual Reports

Current Annual Report
Annual Report 2016

Annual Report 2016: Bearing the Burdens; Restoring the Church

In serving Christian ministries, Brotherhood Mutual carries on a tradition that dates back to the early church. Just as Aaron and Hur raised Moses’ arms when he grew weary in battle, we come alongside ministries when they need support.  

Download the PDF

Previous Annual Reports
Annual Report 2015

Annual Report 2015: Your Ministry Matters

When hope is dearly needed, ministries resolve to shine. That’s why Brotherhood Mutual celebrates the work of more than 52,000 ministry customers in this year’s annual report.  

View the website | Download the PDF

Annual Report 2014

Annual Report 2014: Inspiration

At Brotherhood Mutual, we’re inspired daily by the creative ways ministries are reaching people. Hearing success stories inspires us to continually improve and expand our coverages, so we can provide the type of service ministries deserve.

Download the PDF 


Annual Report 2013

Annual Report 2013: Connections

In 2013, we explored many new avenues to interact with ministries. Through video, Web, and social media, we’ve strengthened our connection with our policyholders. We’ve been inspired by their stories of lives changed and hope restored. Such stories renew our company’s commitment to serving the church.

Download the PDF

Annual Report 2012

Annual Report 2012: Heart to Make a Difference

Annual reports are supposed to be about a company’s numbers and are useful in understanding its business for a given time. But numbers only tell part of the story. They don’t reveal the heart of a company. Our 2012 annual report shows how what we do affects the ministries we serve. It’s about our heart—our mission to advance the Kingdom by serving the Church.

View the website | Download the PDF

Annual Report 2011

Annual Report 2011: Performing Strongly

When we talk about 2011, we will remember it as a record year for the insurance industry. Not for dollars gained for business growth, but for the sheer number of lives touched by devastating storms. Together with our policyholders, we were able to help neighbor churches and ministries weather the storms and continue to advance the Kingdom. It was a year that defined what it means to be “mutual.”

Download the PDF

Annual Report 2010

Annual Report 2010

Brotherhood Mutual prevailed again in 2010, a year weighted with uncertain market and weather conditions. Most importantly, we kept our promises to the churches and ministries we insure. As a customer said to one of our claims adjusters, “Brotherhood Mutual treats us so well that we don’t want anyone else to insure us.” Comments like that make us thankful and even more dedicated to our mission of “Advancing the Kingdom by serving the Church®.”

Download the PDF

Annual Report 2009

Annual Report 2009: Advancing the Kingdom

Brotherhood Mutual's approach to an insurance purchase embraces an ongoing relationship, not just a dollar transaction. Our new mission statement, Advancing the Kingdom by Serving the Church®, helps solidify the truth that the work of our agents and employees is ultimately directed at making sure our customers are free to do the work of ministry in a wise and safe fashion.

Download the PDF