Leadership Team

 Our expert team at work for you

Brotherhood Mutual's leadership team is made up of people who know your needs and design products and services to meet them. Here are some of the characteristics that make them distinctive:

  • Long-Term Experience: Our executives have a combined total of almost two centuries' worth of experience at Brotherhood and almost a quarter-millennium in the insurance industry.
  • Industry Designations: Not only have our leaders earned industry designations such as the CIC and CPCU, several of them have held significant positions in state and national insurance industry organizations.
  • Commitment to Ministry: Everyone on the leadership team is active in a church or related ministry. For these people, such activity is more than a market niche—it's a personal commitment.

Mark A. Robison, CPA, CPCU
Chairman and President

Michael J. Allison, JD, CPCU
Vice President, Chief Counsel and Secretary

Dan Book, CIC, AIC 
Vice President, Sales

Scott A. Figgins, CPCU
Vice President, Underwriting

Matt G. Hirschy, CPA, CPCU
Vice President and Treasurer

Dave Lantz, CPCU, AIC
Vice President, Claims

Daryl Pannabecker, CPCU
Vice President, Information Systems

Mitzi Thomas, ABC
Vice President, Marketing

Kathleen Turpin, JD, CPCU, AIM
Vice President, Human Resources

Hugh White, M.Div., CPCU
Vice President, Strategic Relationships

Gabriel S. Brown, CPCU, AIC
Assistant Vice President, Sales and Special Markets

Kathy Bruce
Assistant Vice President, Agency Marketing Services

Steve Case, JD
Assistant Vice President, Senior Corporate Counsel

Rick Crow, CPCU
Assistant Vice President, Application Architecture

Jennifer Hansen, CPA, CPCU
Assistant Vice President, Finance/Controller

Chris Harvey, CPCU
Assistant Vice President, Network Architecture

Thomas L. Lichtenberger, MBA, CPCU
Assistant Vice President, Property Claims

Jeff Renbarger
Assistant Vice President, Marketing

Sabra Rowley, CPA
Assistant Vice President, Affiliate Operations

Steven R. Smith, CPCU, ARM
Assistant Vice President, Underwriting

Joshua L. Spencer, ACAS, ASA, MAAA, CERA, CPCU
Assistant Vice President, Chief Actuary

Matthew Zurbuch
Assistant Vice President, Investments

Board of Directors