Commercial Auto Insurance Claims

Reporting Options

There are three ways that you can report your commercial auto claims:

  • Contact your Brotherhood Mutual insurance agent.
  • Report your claim online.
  • For after-hours emergencies, call our emergency claim line: 1-800-933-1849.
Auto Glass Insurance Claims

To report an auto glass claim, please call our partners, Safelite® Solutions, at 800.382.2926.

Rental Vehicle Claims

For damages to vehicles rented by your ministry, please submit a Liability Claim.


Not sure you need to file a claim? Ask your Brotherhood Mutual agent for advice.


Don't have your agent's contact info handy? We'll help you look it up.

Learn More About Our Claims Process
Need To Report a Different Type of Claim?
Select the type of claim you need to report:

How We'll Handle Your Claim
Whether you’re reporting a simple fender-bender or a catastrophe, Brotherhood Mutual follows this simple five-step process when we’re resolving your loss.

When a Loss Occurs
Know what to do ahead of time so your ministry is ready when a loss occurs.

Common Questions
Let us answer your questions about the claim process.

Agency Contact Information

To look up your agency's contact information please enter your policy number and billing ZIP code:

Policy Number:
Where can I find this?
(Last six digits)
Billing ZIP Code: