Here to Help Christian Ministries Thrive

Insuring 65,000+ Churches
and Related Ministries.

Request a Quote

First Prairie Creek Baptist Church
Kevin Dobson

“The rebuilding process went fairly smoothly for us. From the first phone call through receiving the last check from Brotherhood Mutual, I was always left with the impression that Brotherhood Mutual cared about our church and wanted to help out in any way they could.”

You are called to build the Kingdom.
We are called to protect you in that mission.

As a specialist in ministry-focused insurance, we use a comprehensive approach to custom-build policies which protect your people, property, and reputation.



Our liability policies are carefully crafted by ministry specialists to fill coverage gaps and protect your people from the unique risks faced by Christian organizations.



Beyond basic financial protection for your building, our property insurance provides the support you need for holistic recovery and continued ministry.



We're in the business of protecting your ministry from anything that might threaten your ability to serve confidently and effectively — before, during, or after an incident.

Serving Christian Ministries

Explore some of our innovative insurance products, services, and risk management resources.

Helping Ministries Thrive

  • Brotherhood Mutual allows us to do ministry on the edge and still know that we have backup, and that's huge. They're developing products with enough foresight to see creative ministry opportunities.”

    Bob Church
    Administrative Pastor, Sagebrush Community Church

  • More and more people don’t even understand who Christians are, what we believe, and how that informs how we make decisions... but Brotherhood Mutual understands.”

    Michael James, Ed.D.
    Vice President for Business and Finance, Tabor College

  • They watch out for our school on a level beyond what you would expect from an insurance company…taking the initiative to be proactive and reaching out to us, looking at ways to serve us and to bless us.”

    Zach Kassebaum, Ed.D.
    Superintendent, Lincoln Christian School

Request a Free Quote