It's our ministry
to protect yours.

Insuring America's Churches
and Related Ministries.

First Prairie Creek Baptist Church
Kevin Dobson

“The rebuilding process went fairly smoothly for us. From the first phone call through receiving the last check from Brotherhood Mutual, I was always left with the impression that Brotherhood Mutual cared about our church and wanted to help out in any way they could.”

Concordia Lutheran Church
Bill Tucker
Senior Pastor

“Brotherhood Mutual is vested in ministry. They provide services that make our ministry better, safer. It allows us to focus on what we’re called to do, with the absolute confidence that they’re faithfully attending to the details. It gives us a level of confidence so that we can do the things we need to do and know at the same time, we’re being great stewards of the resources that God provides.”

Protect your people, property, and reputation.

Brotherhood Mutual is a leading property and liability insurer for Christian churches, schools, colleges, camps, and ministries. Since 1917, we've been inspired by Paul's charge to the Galatians to "bear one another's burdens and so fulfill the law of Christ."

For us, insurance is more than a contract. Every policy we write, every decision we make is made out of a deep love for the Church and its future.

We're here to serve you, so you can continue to make an impact in your community for years to come.


What Customers Say

  • “Flatirons is rapidly expanding with new campuses and a school. Our agent and Brotherhood Mutual have been with us every step of the way, helping us make sure we’re here to offer the types of ministries that God is calling us to provide.”

    Michael Koehn
    Chief Financial Officer
    Flatirons Community Church

    Michael Koehn
  • “Brotherhood Mutual is usually one step ahead in their coverages compared to others. The insurance package designed for our school fit our specific needs while costing us less money.”

    Birdie Lentz
    Human Resources
    Conway Christian School

    Berdie Lentz
  • “Brotherhood Mutual has taken very good care of Barclay College. They live out Christian principles like ‘love your neighbor as yourself’ in their business dealings.”

    Gayle Mortimer
    Human Resources
    Barclay College

    Gayle Mortimer

Request a Free Quote