label Careers

Serve the Church.
Advance the Kingdom.

The list of ministries we serve keeps growing, and so does our passion to bear burdens. Will you join us?

View open positions

Work with us

We believe Christian churches, schools, and ministries should get to focus on their calling, without being distracted or weighed down by complicated matters like insurance. That’s where you come in.

We’re building a creative, capable team of people who want to find purpose in what they do. Every employee — from Building and Grounds, to Claims, to IT — has a hand in serving more than 67,000 Christian ministries across the country.

Purpose-driven careers

Career Paths

  • Administration & clerical
  • Building & grounds
  • Claims
  • Customer service
  • Event services
  • Finance
  • Human resources
  • Information technology
  • Legal
  • Marketing
  • Office services
  • Payroll services
  • Research & development
  • Risk control
  • Sales
  • Underwriting

Benefits

  • Wellness center with on-site health clinic
  • Competitive pay & PTO plans
  • Profit sharing
  • Insurance package and 401k match
  • Generous employer HSA contribution
  • 401K employer match
  • Educational reimbursement
  • Parental leave and adoption assistance
  • Fitness center, café, and game room on-site

Rewarding Work

Opportunities

  • Weekly chapel opportunity
  • Bonus personal day for community service
  • Professional development opportunities
  • Ongoing internal training and development
  • Remote work Wednesdays
  • Mission trip matching donation
  • Career advancement opportunities
  • Robust wellness program

Outlook

  • Insure more than 67,000 ministries
  • Voted one of Indiana’s “Best Places to Work” and BPTW Hall of Fame
  • A- Insurance Financial Strength Rating by Kroll (KBRA) - Outlook Stable
  • B++ (Good) financial strength rating by AM Best
  • More than $812 million in Direct Written Premiums in 2023
  • 650+ employees and growing steadily
  • More than 100 years in the industry

Employee Spotlight

Rich DeWitte

Manager, Estimating

“This is a wonderfully collaborative group and the work life balance is excellent.

I’m glad that I found Brotherhood Mutual and my only regret is that it didn’t happen earlier.”

Laura Richards

Enterprise Data Specialist III, IT

“I feel blessed to be part of this culture that is built on grace.

You’ll find so much grace in working with the people here. Brotherhood Mutual feels like home.”

Salvador Espinoza

Account Executive, Marketing

“Our mission of advancing the kingdom gives purpose to what I do.

And I appreciate that we get time every week for worship.”

Work with us

View open positions

Agent Opportunities

Brotherhood Mutual is represented by independent agents in 47 states and the District of Columbia. Agents earn a competitive commission and may be eligible for incentive trips and awards.


Call us at 1-800-333-3735 extension 7949.