Our full website is currently offline for maintenance. We apologize for any inconvenience. In the meantime, you can still access Legal Assist, Claims, and My Account. Thank you for your patience as we work to bring the website back online soon.

My Account

Manage Payments, File a Claim, Access eDocuments, Get eNotifications.

My Account Login

Legal AssistSM

Our in-house Legal team offers helpful risk-management guidance as a free service to Christian ministries.*

Ask a Question

Powered by Atlassian's - JIRA Management Service

Careers

We're building a creative, capable team of people who want to find purpose in what they do. Will you join us?

Explore Careers

Report a Claim

Hours: Monday-Friday, 8 a.m.-4:30 p.m. EDT

After Hours Emergency Claims Line: 800-933-1849
A representative will return your call as soon as possible.

Property & Liability
Commercial Auto

Report Online

My Account

or

Call Us

800-333-3371

Auto Glass Claims
Safelite®

800-382-2926

Workers’ Comp

Each state has specific requirements. Check your policy documents for instructions on completing a First Notice of Injury Report form.

Once completed, email to claims@brotherhoodmutual.com or fax to 800-284-9579.

If you need assistance, call the Claims line at 800-333-3371.

Mission Travel

Faith Ventures

Call Us

888-674-4074

Fire, Flood, and Smoke Recovery:
Call ServiceMaster Restore® at: 1-800-RESPOND (1-800-737-7663)