What Customers Say

We do everything we can to serve our customers well, and we know we've achieved it when they're willing to share their stories. Listen to what our customers have to say about the service they received from Brotherhood Mutual.

What others are saying about Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company.

  • Concordia Lutheran Church
    Bill Tucker
    Senior Pastor

    “Brotherhood Mutual is vested in ministry. They provide services that make our ministry better, safer. It allows us to focus on what we’re called to do, with the absolute confidence that they’re faithfully attending to the details. It gives us a level of confidence so that we can do the things we need to do and know at the same time, we’re being great stewards of the resources that God provides.”

  • First Prairie Creek Baptist Church
    Kevin Dobson

    “The rebuilding process went fairly smoothly for us. From the first phone call through receiving the last check from Brotherhood Mutual, I was always left with the impression that Brotherhood Mutual cared about our church and wanted to help out in any way they could.”

We'd Love to Hear Your Story


Geyer Springs First Baptist Church
Joe Statton
Executive Pastor

“We’ve been a Brotherhood Mutual customer for more than 30 years. They have a great product with competitive pricing, and they’re responsive to our claims. I’ve always had a good experience with Brotherhood Mutual.”


Missionary Church USA
Don Williams
Director of Operations

“I deeply appreciate the ministry you provide through Legal Assist. I recommend you almost every week to the family of churches throughout the Missionary Church USA.”