Serve the Church. Advance the Kingdom.

We believe Christian churches, schools, and ministries should get to focus on their calling, without being distracted or weighed down by complicated matters like insurance. That’s where you come in.

We’re building a creative, capable team of people who want to find purpose in what they do. Every employee — from Building and Grounds, to Claims, to IT — has a hand in serving more than 65,000 Christian ministries across the country.

The list of ministries we have the honor to serve grows every day, and so does our passion for our mission. New, exciting challenges lie ahead — new territories, new ways of doing ministry, new opportunities to bear the burdens of Christian ministries across the country. Will you join us?


Purpose-Driven Careers

Career Paths

  • Administration & Clerical
  • Building & Grounds
  • Claims
  • Customer Service
  • Events
  • Finance
  • Human Resources
  • Information Technology
  • Legal
  • Marketing
  • Office Services
  • Payroll Services
  • Research & Development
  • Risk Control
  • Sales
  • Underwriting


  • Competitive pay and time off
  • Profit sharing through E.P.I.C. program
  • Full Medical/Dental/Life insurance
  • Generous Employer HSA deposit
  • 401K employer match
  • Educational reimbursement
  • Designation incentive program
  • Adoption assistance benefit



Life at Brotherhood Mutual


Rewarding Work


  • Voluntary chapel
  • Streamlined on-boarding process
  • Bonus personal day for community service
  • Professional development opportunities (conferences/training)
  • Ongoing internal training and development
  • Mission trip matching donation
  • Career advancement opportunities
  • Robust wellness program


  • Insure more than 68,000 ministries
  • Voted one of Indiana’s “Best Places to Work” and BPTW Hall of Fame
  • A- Insurance Financial Strength Rating by Kroll (KBRA) - Outlook Stable
  • B++ (Good) financial strength rating by AM Best
  • More than $812 million in Direct Written Premiums in 2023
  • 600+ employees and growing steadily
  • More than 100 years in the industry

Employee Spotlight

"This is a wonderfully collaborative group and the work-life balance is excellent. I’m glad that I found Brotherhood Mutual and my only regret is that it didn’t happen earlier."
~ Rich, Manager, Estimating
"I feel blessed to be part of this culture that is built on grace. You’ll find so much grace in working with the people here."
~ Laura, Enterprise Data Specialist III
"Since day one, people have gone out of their way to make me feel welcome. I feel like I truly belong.”
~ Sara, Claims Adjuster I
“Our mission of advancing the kingdom gives purpose to what I do. And I appreciate that we get time every week for worship.”
~ Salvador, Associate Account Executive
"The culture here will help you get to where you want to be. You never feel intimidated while working here. The people are always helpful and make you feel welcome."
~ Durand, Manager, Regulatory & Compliance
"Protecting ministries through times of crisis is truly fulfilling work."
~ Emily, Underwriter II

Life in Fort Wayne