Leadership Team

Brotherhood Mutual's leadership team is made up of people who know your needs and design products and services to meet them. Here are some of the characteristics that make them distinctive:

  • Long-Term Experience: Our executive team members have served at Brotherhood Mutual for an average of 18 years. This experience gives them a firm understanding of the issues facing Christian ministries.
  • Industry Designations: Not only have our leaders earned industry designations, such as the CIC and CPCU, but several of them also have held significant positions in state and national insurance industry organizations.
  • Commitment to Ministry: Everyone on the leadership team is active in a church or related ministry. For these people, such activity is more than a market niche—it's a personal commitment.

Senior Executive Staff


Mark A. Robison

CPA, CPCU
Chairman & President


Scott A. Figgins

MBA, CPCU
Senior Vice President
Insurance Operations


Matthew G. Hirschy
CPA, CPCU
Senior Vice President & Treasurer


Michael J. Allison

JD, CPCU
Vice President, Chief Counsel & Secretary


Dan Book

CIC, AIC
Vice President
Sales


Jennifer Hansen

CPA, MBA, CPCU
Vice President
Finance


Dave Lantz

CPCU, AIC
Vice President
Claims


Daryl Pannabecker

CPCU
Vice President
Information Technology


Steven R. Smith

MBA, CPCU, ARM, ARe
Vice President
Underwriting


Josh Spencer

ACAS, ASA, MAAA, CERA, CPCU
Chief Actuary, Vice President
Research & Development


Mitzi Thomas

ABC
Vice President
Marketing


Kathleen J. Turpin

JD, CPCU, AIM
Vice President
Human Resources


Executive Staff


Brad Bertsch

CPA, CPCU, AIAF
Assistant Vice President
Finance


Gabriel Brown

CPCU, CIC, AIC
Assistant Vice President
Sales & Special Markets


Kathy Bruce

Assistant Vice President
Agency Marketing Services


Steve Case

JD, CPCU
Assistant Vice President
Senior Corporate Counsel


Rick Crow

CPCU
Assistant Vice President
IT – Application Architecture


Dustin Grogg

CPCU, ARM, ARe
Assistant Vice President
Underwriting


Chris Harvey

CPCU
Assistant Vice President
IT – Network Architecture


Mark Landrigan

CPA
Assistant Vice President
MinistryWorks


Thomas Lichtenberger

MBA, CPCU, AIC, AIM
Assistant Vice President
Property Claims


Jeff Renbarger

Assistant Vice President
Marketing & Communications


Sabra Rowley

CPA, CPCU
Assistant Vice President
Affiliate Operations


Matthew Zurbuch

Assistant Vice President
Investments


Board of Directors


Mark A. Robison
CPA, CPCU
Chairman of the Board & President
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company


Michael J. Allison
JD, CPCU
Vice President, Chief Counsel & Secretary
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company


Matthew G. Hirschy
CPA, CPCU
Senior Vice President & Treasurer
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company


Garrett W. Cooper
Investment Strategist
Pinnacle Consulting Group


Chris L. Goeglein
Managing Principal
True North Strategic Advisors, LLC


Sammy T. Mah
Private Consultant
Former President & CEO
World Relief


Suzanne Allison-Davis
JD, MBA
Executive Vice President & Chief Legal Officer
Greenville University


Kathy B. Rogers
CSP
President & CEO
KB Search Team, LLC


Ryan Skoog
Founder & President
Fly For Good;
Co-Founder & President
Venture Expeditions


Tim Turner
President & CEO
Subsplash, Inc.


Robert Wallstrom
Chief Executive Officer
Vera Bradley