Why Choose Us?

We'll Give You Five Good Reasons

Because we've been insuring churches for more than a century, we understand the unique needs of ministry. Every year, we work with thousands of Christian churches, schools, camps, colleges and universities, and mission organizations. 

Here are 5 good reasons why you should buy your ministry's insurance from us:

1. Superior Products

Your organization deserves better than one-size-fits-all insurance coverage. With Brotherhood Mutual, you’ll get comprehensive insurance designed specifically to meet the unique risks and challenges of ministry. And our insurance scales to fit your organization, whether it is large or small.

2. Outstanding Claim Service

More than 98% of our customers say we handled their insurance claims fairly, promptly, and courteously.

3. Financial Strength

We work with some of the leading rating services for insurance companies to do an independent analysis of our financial strength each year. Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA) consistently rates our company with an A- insurance financial strength rating (IFSR) and a rating of BBB to the company’s currently outstanding surplus notes. The Outlook for all ratings is Stable. Additionally, we consistently earn an A- (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best, who categorizes our balance sheet as strong and our financial strength as stable.

4. Ministry-Affiliated Agents

Our independent agents are involved in local ministry. Their professionalism, care, and experience set them apart from other insurance salespeople.

5. Commitment

We share your passion for ministry and building the Kingdom. We’re committed to the church and related ministry market. It’s the only one we serve.