Report a Claim

Claims can be disruptive to your mission. Let's make this as easy on you as possible.

Hours: Monday-Friday, 8 a.m.-4:30 p.m. EDT

After Hours Emergency Claims Line: 800-933-1849
A representative will return your call as soon as possible.

Property & Liability
Commercial Auto

Report Online

My Account


Call Us


Auto Glass Claims


Workers’ Comp

Each state has specific requirements. Check your policy documents for instructions on completing a First Notice of Injury Report form.

Once completed, email to or fax to 800-284-9579.

If you need assistance, call the Claims line at 800-333-3371.

Mission Travel

Faith Ventures

Call Us


Fire, Flood, and Smoke Recovery:
Call ServiceMaster Restore® at: 1-800-RESPOND (1-800-737-7663)

A claims agent with a headset on

Our Heart is to
Serve You Well

Our claims team is different. They often are involved in ministry, volunteer with their church, and serve on boards. Rest assured when you call, the claims member on the other end walks in step with you. They are experienced and ready to serve your ministry throughout the claims process.


Answers to Common Questions


Helpful Resources


Think of it like a good cup of coffee.

Visit Webpage


A handy step-by-step guide helps you organize.

Free Download

Glossary of
Insurance Terms

Plain language for tricky terms.

Read the List

Prevent Frozen Pipes • Prepare Ministry Property

Brotherhood Mutual customers:
Get advanced notice of extreme cold.

Sign Up Today!