Business Release
Erica Smith Promoted to Assistant Vice President

Effective February 18, 2024, Erica Smith, CPA, CPCU, BIDA, will become assistant vice president underwriting operations. Her responsibilities include underwriting operations including risk control services, estimating, underwriting services, and data and quality services. She most recently served as director of underwriting product quality and development. She joined the company in 2022. Before coming to Brotherhood Mutual, she spent 11 years with Shelter Insurance Companies.

Erica holds a bachelor’s degree in accounting and business administration from Southwest Baptist University. She has earned several professional designations including CPA, CPCU, and BIDA. Erica serves on the NAMIC Commercial and Personal Lines Committee and actively engages with Brotherhood Mutual's CoMission teams. She also serves in the financial ministry at Pathway Community Church.


About Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Celebrating more than 100 years in business, Brotherhood Mutual® is a national property and casualty insurance company with a heart for helping Christian ministries thrive. As a leader in the industry, Brotherhood Mutual provides innovative insurance coverage and risk management resources, specifically designed for ministries, to help them operate safely and effectively. The company serves more than 67,000 churches, schools, colleges and universities, camps, and mission organizations in 47 states and the District of Columbia. Additionally, Brotherhood Mutual provides access to payroll and tax filing services, employee health benefits, auto insurance, workers’ compensation insurance, and mission travel insurance. Headquartered in Fort Wayne, IN, Brotherhood Mutual is staffed by 600+ employees and works with 424 independent agents in 93 agencies nationwide.