Why Choose Us

  We’ll give you five good reasons

We Share Your Passion for Ministry.

Because we've been insuring churches for more than 90 years, we understand the unique needs of ministry. Every year we work with thousands of Christian camps, colleges, schools, and churches. Our insurance can be tailored to fit any ministry, large or small. You won’t find such coverage—or care—anywhere else. We share your passion for ministry.

Here are 5 good reasons why you should buy your ministry's insurance from us.

Superior Products

Your ministry deserves better than one-size-fits-all insurance coverage. With Brotherhood Mutual, you’ll get a product designed specifically for churches and related ministries.

Outstanding Claim Service

More than 98 percent of our customers say we handled their insurance claims fairly, promptly, and courteously.

Financial Strength

We consistently outperform the insurance industry. National Underwriter magazine calls us one of the 50 “champions” among property-casualty insurers. A.M. Best Company, the leading insurance authority, consistently awards Brotherhood Mutual an A (excellent) rating.

Ministry-Affiliated Agents

Our independent agents are involved in local ministry. Their professionalism, care, and experience set them apart from other insurance salespeople.


We’re committed to the church and related ministry market. It’s the only one we serve.

Learn more about us by reading our Company Overview (PDF, 42 Kb)